NYC’s beloved dollar slice is back —here’s where pizza lovers can find the bargain

TDY News

Once again, four quarters can buy you a little slice of heaven.

The beloved dollar pizza slice may be a much-missed relic of the recent past, but at least one pizza proprietor’s doing what he can to give his customers more bang for their buck.

Sana Ullah is back to selling slices for a buck at his two East Village joints — BD Star Pizza and 99 Cent Pizza — after charging patrons $1.50 starting last spring.

Sana Ullah with a whole pie at his BD Star Pizza shop.
Sana Ullah is back to selling slices for a buck at his two East Village joints after charging patrons $1.50 starting last spring.Helayne Seidman
Christopher Batista, 34, (L) and Dwayne Sumpter, 30, bite into their pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza shop on Avenue A.
Two men bite into their pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza shop on Avenue A.Helayne Seidman

“I think one dollar is reasonable” for a slice, Ullah told The Post. “For so many, it’s the same thing. People [are] struggling. Yes, I sell more [slices], but also, I help people.

Customers are happy to save some dough.

“I had to rub my eyes there for a second,” said Chris Hinds, who spotted Ullah’s “99¢ Pizza” signs from two blocks away. “No one sells dollar slices anymore,” so “at a time when we’re all paying more for everything, it’s nice to see that its making a comeback.”

Frank Santangelo, 37, said he, too, is glad to see the true revival of the dollar slice.

“It’s about damn time,” said Santangelo, who lives nearby. “New York City hasn’t felt the same” without the quintessential dollar slice.

Like other shops across the city, rising production costs caused by rampant inflation forced Ullah to increase his cheese slice price to $1.50 in 2022.

“Everything’s gotten more expensive,” Ullah said. “Cheese, flour, napkins, dough.”

Worker Monowar Townhid, 27, with pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza shop on East 14th Street and Second Avenue in the East Village.
“I think one dollar is reasonable” for a slice, Ullah (not pictured) told The Post. “For so many, it’s the same thing. People [are] struggling. Yes, I sell more [slices], but also, I help people.Helayne Seidman
Asanys Payana, 20,  bites into her pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza shop on East 14th Street.
A woman bites into her pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza shop on East 14th Street.Helayne Seidman

Last year, he tried selling dollar slices again at his 99 Cent Pizza shop on East 14th Street, only to raise prices by half-a-dollar within months.

Realizing many of his loyal customers seemed unwilling to fork over an extra 50¢, Ullah went back to selling dollar slices about four months ago, resulting in only a slight uptick in sales.

“If you help someone,” he said, “then someone will help you.”

Ullah said on Friday and Saturday nights, there are usually lines outside BD Star Pizza, located on Avenue A near 6th Street, and 99 Cent Pizza, on East 14th Street between 2nd and 3rd Avenues.

The shop's signs beckon from blocks away.
Ullah said on Friday and Saturday nights, there are usually lines outside BD Star Pizza.Helayne Seidman
Faustyna Karaban, 33, and boyfriend, Joel Diaz, 37, eat their pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza store on East 14th Street.
A couple eats their pizza at the 99 Cents Pizza store on East 14th Street.Helayne Seidman

“Nothing like a dollar slice to soak up the alcohol,” Hinds said.

Pizza lover Gina Bennicasa, 44, gave her BD Star slice a fair “5 out of 10,” calling it a bit too cheesy for her taste.

Lilianne Kailee
Lilianne Kailee
Political coverage specialist and writer at TDY News. She has been featured several times in networks such as the "Newsweek" and "The Independent". Contact at [email protected]

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

spot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Sophistication of AI-backed operation targeting senator points to future of deepfake schemes

An advanced deepfake operation targeted Sen. Ben Cardin, the...

Louvre to Open Byzantine and Greek Orthodox Art Department

A new department dedicated to Byzantine and Eastern Orthodox...